Category Archives: philosophy
A Tiny Disturbance
A Tiny Disturbance
A stoat, or weasel?
too difficult from distance to tell,
waits to emerge
from the verge of clustered
snow white willow catkins,
a moment taken to nose
sky and trail for traffic,
she scatters pollen dust in her dash
to cross to the safety
of dense comfrey and
cow parsley camouflage.
As if ushered
by an oncoming train
through this tunnel
of grey willow and alder,
a light wind rifles
stirring the pollen
disturbed in her crossing.
And to chance,
a spiraling dioecious dance
matches pollen and stigma,
that they might plier
the curved walls of new
bark barrelled vaults.
@BobbyMotherwell 2023
Fragile Wings
Fragile Wings
I’ve found the man I love,
After forty years of trying,
All the dead ends and denying,
The roleplaying and lying,
The costume changing,
And rearranging,
To fit the expectations,
That only I had set.
Until, one day we met.
And out of the drought,
he arrived,
younger and wiser,
than any version I’d contrived,
in those days when I locked the bones away,
Imagining conformity the only way
to mould him,
And here he was,
All along, with gentle flaws,
and fragile wings
which glide, on lost rememberings,
At last, to cast off chiselled chains.
And all now that remains,
Is the child in the man I love.
A Savage Slip
One Savage Slip
A fall from here would be bad. I knew it. My position was precarious; temporary and
finely balanced. Arms, legs, hands, feet; straining, bridging as ties and struts, like equalising
forces, finding friction where they could to maintain my grip on this sodden savage slit of
vertical granite, which was currently doing all it could to repel me onto the distant broken
boulder field below.
I was running out of time. The rock sweated rivulets of rainwater to prize the
temporary purchase my boots and fingers had found to maintain my precarious position.
Every muscle screamed to secure my equilibrium, my place on this rockface. Four points of
contact, lose one and lose them all.
I looked up, my face scraping against the rock’s roughness; grey laden skies offered
no comfort. Rain dripped slowly onto my face from a protruding ledge just five feet above
me. The ledge was my refuge, my escape. If only I could bridge the gap. It would be all or
nothing.
I had to move.
The day had started with clearer skies, sunlight danced brightly with shifting clouds
across the rolling Cairngorm hills, moulding our mood as we made our way towards the crag
at Coire an Lochan which cloaked our route for the day. We walked briskly, the three of us,
buoyant with anticipation of a first attempt at a classic Scottish route. Graded as Very
Difficult, the route was called Savage Slit and was well within our capabilities. Or so we
thought. Kenny was without doubt the fittest of the three; his broad shoulders and powerful
legs could move quickly with a heavily laden rucksack of climbing ironmongery. Eric was
leaner, wiry, with a determination which sometimes outstripped his ability, but always a
positive influence and good partner in trying moments. I was certainly the most accomplished
rock climber of the three, and as such would lead the toughest pitches on the route.
We scurried along the path towards the crag, the weather slowly deteriorating. Clouds
above us thickened, the skies now darker and threatening. The shade of the crag now
hanging imposingly over us. The air cooled and the mist turned wet against our skin. The
base of the climb appeared just above us, a quietness ensued. We scrambled to the belay and
readied ourselves to climb. Harnessed and roped, I clipped the gear, my protection, to my
rucksack loops.
All three of us took our first long look at the dank vertical corner which soared
skyward above us.
‘Looks hell of a wet.’ Eric broke the silence.
‘Gonny be slippy as fuck,’ ventured Kenny.
I nodded calmly. My confidence was at such a high from recent successes in similar
conditions in Glen Coe, that any apprehensions dissolved unnoticed.
‘There are old climbers and bold climbers Bobby,’ Eric said, ‘but there’s no old, bold climbers!’
He winked at me knowingly, then handed me the rope to tie into. I rubbed my hands together.
‘Well, wish me luck,’ I asked as I turned to face the damp dark rockface.
‘Climbing!’
I pulled on the first greasy handhold. It became apparent very quickly that this was
going to be anything but a simple, straightforward climb. My boots slipped on sloping
footholds as I progressed, fingers found rivers of water inside gaping cracks which were lined
with lichen and slid and slithered under pressure. Cold bit into me, sharp granite cut numb
knuckles raw, a sharp wind swept up the crag roaring louder in my ears as I gained height.
My breathing quickened; doubt arrived in each inhale as I could smell and taste its metallic
sickness in my dry mouth.
‘You’ll be wanting to get a runner in soon’ Eric shouted from below.
I stopped, looked down between my legs at Eric and Kenny looking up at me; wide
eyed, wired. I had run out most of the rope, and with only one runner placed about thirty feet
below me, I was looking at a sixty-foot ground fall if I slipped. For the first time in my life,
fear paralysed me.
‘Don’t fall dad.’…. Calum’s voice.
‘We love you Dad; we need you back home.’ …. Ceri’s voice.
‘I hate you going climbing.’ …. Arlene’s voice.
Seconds seemed like an eternity. My senses fought for attention. Emotion roared
through me like a hurricane. Above, a raindrop left the ledge, I watched it rush towards me,
this adrenalin eyedrop splashed urgency on impact. I have never felt so alive.
I had to move.
The Homecoming: Hirta and the Harebell
I had no sooner thrown my wet rucksack on the stone floor and shaken off the rain from my Gore-Tex jacket, than I heard the door to which I had just entered the old St Kilda Black House open and close again behind me. I was no longer alone in the room. Unzipping and Velcro ripping, I removed my jacket, and turned around to welcome the incomer.
His silhouette filled the small door frame; backlit by the tiny windows which bookended the entrance to the house. Now a museum dedicated to the people of the islands, it housed trestle storyboards depicting island life, glass cabinets of clothing, cooking utensils and bird fouling equipment. Day to day items used by the islanders to survive the harsh North Atlantic beatings this gnarled volcanic archipelago had endured, until their reluctant evacuation pleas were heard and granted in 1930. The National Trust had converted old Findlay Gillies’ house into a living history of island life; the others, still ruins, simply had a single painted slate acknowledging the names of the last occupants displayed in the open fire hearth. Old Findlay’s house was given a new roof, windows, and carefully concealed modern conveniences; lighting and heating which was at this moment most welcome. I dropped my wet jacket on the perimeter bench which skirted the substantial stone walls.
He was dressed authentically in traditional islanders clothing, a rehearsal for the next day’s re-enactment of the anniversary of the evacuation. His trousers hung heavy around his waist, ill-fitting and dragging over clumsy shoes. The rough knit jumper, sleeves torn and knotted was covered with the waistcoat favoured by the men of the island. A forerunner to my modern down gilet I thought. A bunnet hugged his head and he wore a bandolier of knotted ropes and a red beard which exploded from his rough, tired features. ‘Top marks to costume.’ I thought. The putrid stench of guano almost permeated.
‘Christ you’re keen,’ I said, scanning head to toe and back again. ‘looks the part, but in this weather?’
At first, I thought he hadn’t heard me, or taken objection to my tone. He fixed me with a stare which I held. Smiling, I awaited a response. He stepped towards me, emerging from the shadow of the door.
‘Did just fine for them,’ he said, glancing at the sepia image on the display beside me. ‘Coped with much worse than this wee drying shower.’
He measured my extents, fixing on the notepad which had fallen from my rucksack and the camera around my neck; his glare relaxed to a knowing grin. His grey eyes swam with mischief and cunning, like a fulmar ready to regurgitate on a nest thief.
‘And you,’ he said. ‘What brings you here this eve? Here to ‘celebrate’ the evacuation? To tell the story of how these poor islanders couldny take care of themselves any longer, had to cry for help? Here to tell their story and in doing so make a name with yours?’
‘Like you,’ I sighed. ‘I’ve got a job to do. Today I clambered the hills of Oesival and Connochair, photographed the Mistress and Lovers Stone, I ran from Dun to Soay and landed on neither, I got pictures of Soay Sheep, St Kilda Wren, Storm Petrels and Puffins till my memory card was full, I fought off at least a dozen attacks from wild bonxies. The rain pissed on me, my feet are soaking wet, my hands sore with hot aches and I’ll struggle tonight to write a piece which will be seen by fewer than five folk on Facebook and disappear never to be looked at again.’
He raised his eyebrows, a grimace graduating to a grin.
‘Well, you have had a tough day …..and for such scant reward! Have a seat ya poor soul ye, get those wet things off your feet and warm them by the fire.’ A flourished palm gestured to the display fireplace set with period ironmongery and fake flames.
Slowly, sheepishly, I gathered my damp notebook and packed my camera away in my rucksack. I walked over to the window to see if there was any sign of the weather clearing, the shallow beach was being swept with white crests, the dark rainclouds were moving quickly on a northerly across Connachair and the bright blue letterbox south of Dun would soon be smiling on the village slopes. The large boat which had brought the TV production team, cast and crew bobbed gently off the pier in the centre of the bay. The charter boat I had arrived on this morning had left to take some paying tourists around the sea stacks. I wanted to get ashore to get acquainted with the island before it filled the next day for the filming of the evacuation. The Elizabeth G would be back in Village Bay in an hour or so to collect me and tie up for the night.
‘I’m sorry for snapping just there,’ I said. ‘letting first world hassles get to me.’
‘Aye, this is nae place for rushing.’ He nodded, looking out the tiny window at the boat in the harbour. ‘worrying about a day that might never come; the gathering of birds, the filling of cleits for winter storage and hoping that it will come and go without loss, and in truth, in no time at all, you’re here and then you’re gone.’
He stared wistfully out at the boat; his chest rising and falling, a symbiosis with the swell of the sea; his monochrome complexion and well weathered face looked much older than I imagined his years. He must have been in his sixties at least.
‘I never saw a man who looked with such a wistful eye, upon that little tent of blue we prisoners call the sky,’ I thought, recalling Wilde’s Reading Gaol captive.
I broke the short silence to scatter his melancholy.
‘Looks like clearing soon, I’d give it an hour.’
‘Oh, so you’re a weatherman then?’
‘I’m a photographer actually,’ I offered my hand. ‘Sorry, my names Fraser – Fraser Macleod? from The Herald?’ I awaited a response. I got none.
‘I’m here to cover the story tomorrow, I’m from Glasgow. Never been here before, read a wee bit about it and seen a few programmes, I’d love to have lived here though eh?’
‘My family were from here.’ he said. ‘generations of them, until gradually like snow off McKay’s church roof they disappeared. Some went willingly overseas, some were taken by smallpox and flu, and those remaining boarded the Harebell and left all they knew to save themselves. I return every year to remember them and the others. Live here? would you? You wouldn’t last one winter.’
‘You’re awfy quick to judge. You don’t know anything about me.’
‘I call what I see, and I see a towny, you’ve never been unwrapped from the blanket ye were Christened in, assuming of course you were Christened? Think you could hang from the cliffs and snatch Guga’s from their nests, wring their necks and six at a time carry them back up the rock face with the tides tearing at your ankles below, could you do that son?’
‘Aye, I think I could actually, if I had to…’
‘… and live on porridge, rationed eggs and bird flesh, and what vegetables could be scraped from this barren soil?…’
‘Why would I have to?’ I interrupted. ‘no one has to live like that these days.’
He wasn’t hearing me.
‘… and when the long dark evenings arrive and the only heat from the lamps is sucked out through these doors and walls, and the weans huddle together with the beasts, and your never-ending struggle to feed them is second only to your struggle to keep the invading tuberculosis from their lungs, and their souls from their maker.’
He wrung his hands together as if washing them clean, then swept both palms down his face. His eyes swam.
‘You think you could live here? Pah!’
‘Was this his script?’ I thought. ‘had he invoked the character?’ I indulged him.
‘Under those conditions I’m not sure anyone would want to.’ I said, ‘but look at this place, unparalleled beauty and mystery. I walked for hours today and left everything from home behind, OK so it was wet, but no phone calls, no emails, no worries. I wasn’t tied to a schedule or a clock. I was in the moment, surrounded by this wild natural world. What was it the Vikings called it? Hilda – the fresh spring goddess and source of everything. I was that Viking, and it was my source.’
The wind had chased the clouds and sunlight shone through the windows as the sky over Dun rolled back and the rain on the roof subsided.
‘I would have this in a minute.’ I whispered. ‘In a minute.’
“Aye, there’s none of us who wouldn’t have this in a minute, riches beyond trinkets from tourists and fortunes from Fulmar feathers. But there comes a point when the harsh reality takes its toll; and when Mary Gillies died of appendicitis and Nurse Barclay suggested that there was nothing else for it but evacuation, well there was no option. Even Neil Ferguson who was the only one against it to the bitter end knew it was a matter of survival when he got the sign.’
‘The sign? what sign?’
‘The day the beach was taken.’
‘The beach was taken. I never heard that story?’
‘It was the day after the Parliament had voted to request an evacuation, some of the men had been offered jobs in forestry and houses in Morven. Men who had never seen a tree before in their lives, would trade fulmar lures and hemp ropes for timber yards and fir felling to sustain them. Neil was totally against it.’
” God gave us this land and its beasts to live on and honour him, we will be rejecting the Lord himself if we flee.” were his words as he stormed off that night. And the night came and went, and with it the most brutal storm the islands had seen in years, wave upon wave lashed the shore, the winds ripping at the roofs and doors. And in the morning, when it had subsided, they saw him standing on the beach. But the beach was gone. The sand had been taken by the sea and deposited in its place, a sign straight from his maker, was a single washed up tree trunk. At that moment, Neil knew God had another purpose for him and wanted him to leave.’
He exhaled slowly and deliberately and looked at me, his eyes gentle and heavy, then he looked out again to Village Bay.
‘Well,’ he said ‘there’s work still to be done before tomorrow. I’ll see you then.’
He grabbed the forged latch of the door handle, swung the door open and stepped out into the overgrown narrow furrow that was once the High Street.
A warm breeze rushed through the doorway and the sunlight carpeted the floor, the fulmars cawed to the clear skies across on Dun. I gathered my bag and jacket and walked out into the glare.
I heard a motor start up and saw the orange rib cut a fresh white trail across the bay. On his way to pick me up and return me to the Elizabeth G was Rob, our skipper. I walked slowly down to the pier and arrived just as Rob was securing the inflatable for my boarding. I handed him my rucksack and stepped onto the rib.
‘Good day?’ he enquired.
‘Apart from the weather at times, but yes, a great day!’
‘Good to go then?’ he asked checking I was secured. ‘what are you looking for?’
I was staring back towards old Findlay’s Black House.
‘Aren’t we going to give the guy from the production unit a lift to his boat?’
‘What guy? You’ve had the island to yourself all day.’
The Silence was Deafening
The Silence was Deafening.
From the window a lull,
The rolling rail track thunder rolled back,
Tarmac popping pneumatic air pockets retired,
Rolls Royce roar of take-off and land, banned,
All car, carriage and undercarriage receding,
Doppler affects.
A roaring wind hush ushers pees-weeping lapwing,
Craws caw, starlings copy and the blackbird pilots his patch,
New morning sounds,
Which over once was drowned,
with ears too busy to notice,
natures detail.
“But humans are natural too,” you say,
“and make sounds that bring you to tears of joy;
notes and words which shake the bluebird
in your chest.”
“That’s fine,” I say, “but all the rest,
is best, unsaid.”
…..and from you,
the silence was deafening.
Bobby Motherwell ©️2021
St Kilda, and the GOAT.
We stood on the bow of the Elizabeth G, as she slowed into the serenity of Village Bay. This felt more like a homecoming than an arrival. The nine-hour torturous crossing from Barra across the relentless Minch was now behind us; spent mostly in my cabin fighting sea sickness and a real fear of our ship being torn in two by the sea, such was the swell. We had been delivered safely; relief palpable as the cloud began to lift over the slopes of Oieseval. I drank in this evening view. The culmination of a thirty-year fascination with this group of islands was at hand. As the boat slowed, as if in reverence, the others readied busily for their first dive. I settled down with a Balvenie and my thoughts. Like painted watchmen, the puffins on the Dun cliffs returned my gaze. Realisation dawned that I was here because of Ewan, and Valentino Rossi.
I met Ewan through work; a site visit around three years previously. I nodded at a picture of Rossi behind his desk, he asked if I was a fan. “I named my son after him” I replied. He smiled that broad, now so familiar smile.
It transpired over the months following, that he had worked on St Kilda. I told him of my obsession. He called one day, a place aboard a diving charter he was on had become available. “I lied that you were a sound bloke, they’re cool for you to join us”. I jumped at the chance. And here I was, privileged, the only non-diver aboard.
Their first dive complete, we drank and ate well, and I wished for the morning to come when I could finally set foot on St Kilda.
As usual we both woke early, fortunate that we were cabin buddies. Ewan and I shared a coffee and chat on deck before the others rose. When they finally surfaced, we lowered my kayak into the water, I wished them luck with their dives and waved them cheerio. I paddled gently towards the beach, the sun on a cloudless sky kissing my neck and hands as the realised excitement coursed through me. The kayak speared the soft beach gently, I tore off the spray deck and I stepped for the first time onto Hirta. I panned around this familiar crescent, the wash of lush green hillside, sweeping shoreline and rising rockface; once merely studied pictures, now a reality.
Over the next few days, I would explore every walkable inch of this island. A rigid daily itinerary emerged: launch kayak in the morning, paddle ashore, explore the island in blissful solitude, return to Village Bay, watch for the Elizabeth G returning, paddle out to meet her. Food, drink, enjoyment and much sharing of stories.
In those days, I consumed all the sights and sounds I had pored over for many years. I tasted the salt air from the sea cliffs and stone cleits which sheltered the fulmar catch. The blast of North Atlantic wind which scoured the cliffs filled my fleece as I climbed the Mistress Stone. I engaged the protective male Skuas who, when alerted by the female of my proximity, would swoop down and strike at my head until I scurried clear of their territory. I lazed on the soft slopes of Conachair, dangled feet over the gaping chasm below the Lovers Stone, felt the warm sun tighten my face as the silence, but for the breeze and caw of the fulmars, brought its meditative solace. I could hear in my head the voices and songs of Ann Gillies and the other women singing together at the sharing of the fulmars, plucked by the men from the cliffs overlooking Boreray.
I entered each of the old houses, now roofless and decaying. A roof slate sat in each fireplace, painted on it was the name of the last inhabitant before the evacuation in 1930. I stood in old Findlay’s front room and looked out the frameless window at Village Bay, imagining how this view moulded the boy and the man during his seventy-four years, and how it looked on that fateful day when he would leave his home never to return.
The trip ended too soon, and we left for home. A flat sea ushered a gentle return as if to reward the perseverance of our outbound struggle. A shoal of dolphins rode our bow, shepherding and welcoming us homeward past the shadow of the Black Cuillin on Skye, back to a more familiar setting. I thought of the evacuee’s journey, their culture abandoned.
On deck, Ewan and I toasted them. “Tae journeys, wi’ good friends”.
Three years have passed. I am on the other side of the world. We have our boarding passes. The departure gate announces that the Melbourne flight from Queenstown will be boarding shortly.
I flick through Facebook posts on my phone. The world around me stops.
“….. tragically Ewan Smith died today in a motorbike accident…”.
I look at Arlene. “Ewan is dead” I say, not quite hearing my own words as my head spins.
I flick through my texts. His last one to me. Only a week ago. Inviting me on a biking trip with him and his boys. I apologised, “…. we’re going to see Ceri in Australia, otherwise I would have loved it.”
“Enjoy Oz” he replied, “there will always be another day!”.
Bellochantuy beach: summer 2018
Bellochantuy beach: summer 2018
We all filed out on a summers day
With a feast to see ourselves through
And to the height of the day, the sun found its way
And the tide rolled back to renew
The levelled sea bed on which to land
gulls feet and beaks of curlew
And where to rest our chairs and fare
All family settled, but a few
And rushing to the frothing wake, they ran
through silt sands and pebble stanes,
to pull up short, when sharp sea shock
struck shins like bamboo canes.
A ball was found and kicked around
High, and higher still
And strings brought down to add to the sound,
of fun, which the day was filled.
And long we sat; and ate and drank,
and chat and sang aplenty
On the golden sands to vanishing point
We counted less than twenty
And the sun now setting in a downward course
Heat going and skin now tightening
We fuelled the fire and drank some more
Ever presence our wanton benighting
And we long these days for those long days
Where the sun it rose and fell
On our shared laughter and our song
And a bond in which to dwell.
Bobby Motherwell ©️2020
One year sober.
One Year Today.
A year ago today I woke up after a Sunday night in the pub (remember them?) and asked myself if it wasn’t about time to lay off it for a bit, see if I could last a week. And believe me, at the time, that was a big ask. It meant no beer at home after work, coping with a social function on the Friday (I am a social phobic), and the usual ‘social’ visit to the pub on Saturday and Sunday.
I wouldn’t say it was easy, it seemed unnatural to me to be socialising and not drinking and the ‘reward’ of the home beer after work was something I had always looked forward to, but it wasn’t anywhere near as tough as I’d thought.
And here I am, a year of sobriety.
I had planned on having a couple of glasses of Balvenie at Xmas and Hogmanay, but when the time came, I just didn’t feel like it. The bottle still lying unopened awaiting ‘That Day’.
I share this simply to mark the day, and to illustrate how we can, if we want to, rewire our thought circuitry and regain control. I have never felt better in my life.
Hard fields, blue skies in January
Hard fields, blue skies, January
Flitting
Branch to branch
Before, behind
Along the river bank he follows.
Looking well
enough fed for the month
He stays tight, watching
for turned footprints
to reveal quarry
But feet slip on perma clods of turf
and iced oasis
giving up little.
I’ll take a digestive tomorrow
I decide
And share it
Broken to crumbs, palm open
Trusted.
©️Bobby Motherwell